Local Environmentalist Group Wins Supreme Court of Canada Case

Supreme Court of Canada

Supreme Court of Canada threw out a damages claim for millions from local developers against a local group of environmentalists.

The Pointes Protection Association (PPA) – mainly made up of residents living on Pointe Louise Drive – are opposed to the proposed development of the Pointe Estates subdivision. That development project was first approved by the Sault Ste Marie Region Conservation Authority in 2012. It was a controversial decision which came after some heated debate – only to be rejected by the city council. The developers unsuccessfully appealed that decision to the Ontario Municipal Board.

What followed the OMB appeal was a lawsuit by 1704604 Ontario Limited against the PPA for $6 million in damages. The PPA contended that the lawsuit was only meant to intimidate residents from speaking out on the matter, adding the company’s legal action amounted to a “strategic lawsuit against public participation,” otherwise known as a “SLAPP.”

In its decision, the Supreme Court cited laws in Ontario that stop so-called SLAPPs from going to trial, adding they are not about genuine legal claims. The case marks the first time the Supreme Court has dealt with Ontario’s SLAPP laws.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here